Overweight, aging baseball fan Joe Boyd makes a pact with the Devil so the hapless Washington Senators can win the pennant just once, and is transformed into a young power hitter. Though nearly trapped by a soul-greedy Devil and tempted by his reluctant but luscious sidekick Lola, Joe ultimately decides to return to his wife. A modern re-telling of the Faust tale.
| Benny Van Buren.... | Mike Antoniades |
| Bouley / Commissioner.... | Jimmy McQuaid |
| Doris Miller.... | Gisell Jeter |
| Gloria Thrope.... | Noelle Macheda |
| Henry.... | Michael Turner |
| Joe Boyd / Joe Hardy.... | Chase Levy |
| Linville.... | Andrew Padilla |
| Lola.... | Alice Rosenthal |
| Meg Boyd.... | Adriana Stimola |
| Mickey / Postmaster.... | John Melamed |
| Miss Weston / Chorus.... | Sarah Feder |
| Mr. Applegate.... | Jonathan McDevitt |
| Mr. Welch / Ballplayer.... | Andrew Danish |
| Ms. Lynch / Chorus.... | Maritza Chan |
| Rocky.... | Todd Squitieri |
| Sister Miller.... | Amanda Mikelberg |
| Smokey.... | Drew Hirsh |
| Sohovik.... | Joey Buffa |
| Chorus / Featured Dancer.... | Clara Frias |
| Chorus / Featured Dancer.... | Tiffany Valens |
| Chorus / Featured Dancer.... | Rosa Valiente |
| Chorus.... | Allison Albeen |
| Chorus.... | Megan Campbell |
| Chorus.... | Kayleigh Hanson |
| Chorus.... | Jeany Kwon |
| Chorus.... | Michelle Ovalle |
| Chorus.... | Alexis Pancrazi |
| Directed by | Melanie Amber Diaz |
| Assistant Directed by | Melissa Diaz |
| Choreography by | Melanie Amber Diaz |
| Musical Direction by | Carolyn Russo |
| Band Directed by | Lawrence Silverman |